One of the futures imagined in “The Alternative” is a bleak one for the United Kingdom. The changes sweeping the country affect not only its social and economic life, but also its territorial integrity. London steadily loses influence, suffers defeats in proxy wars, and faces strengthening nationalist movements. The regions grow increasingly unwilling to have their futures determined by the central government.
In the novel, Scotland leaves the United Kingdom after the publication of a new white paper and an independence referendum.
In September 2026, that prediction takes on renewed relevance amid changes in British politics. On September 14, the leaders of Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland signed a memorandum of cooperation and asserted their countries’ right to determine their own futures, calling on London to prepare for constitutional change.
Scotland has already held an independence referendum. In 2014, 55.3% voted to remain in the United Kingdom and 44.7% voted to leave. Brexit gave the debate a new context. A majority of Scottish voters supported remaining in the European Union, but that was not enough to determine the outcome of the UK-wide referendum.
It is a distinctly British predicament. Scotland votes for one future, the UK as a whole votes for another, and democracy helpfully invites everyone to live with the collective result.
Yet when it comes to Scotland’s own future, the decision is not entirely Edinburgh’s to make, either. In 2022, the UK Supreme Court ruled that the Scottish Parliament could not hold another independence referendum on its own without the consent of the UK Parliament.
Against that backdrop, the current cooperation among Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland is especially telling. Their leaders have asserted the right to determine their countries’ futures and urged London to prepare for constitutional change. The issue now reaches beyond a dispute between Edinburgh and Westminster. It raises a broader question: how closely do the interests of the UK’s constituent parts align with decisions made by the central government?
In the novel, Scotland ultimately leaves the United Kingdom as regional movements gain strength and demands for self-government grow. Today’s political landscape makes that scenario seem plausible.
Another prediction in the book offers an unexpected parallel with current events.
In September, residents of Piddington, a village in Oxfordshire, held a symbolic referendum on leaving the United Kingdom. The vote was prompted by plans to house up to 1,256 asylum seekers at a former military base nearby. A total of 285 people voted for “independence,” with 26 opposed.
The vote is not legally binding, but the story is striking in light of another possibility raised in the novel. The author suggests that large-scale immigration could eventually transform Britain’s demographic makeup so profoundly that the native British population would no longer constitute a majority.
Two strands of the book’s imagined future thus intersect unexpectedly in today’s British politics: the question of territorial self-determination and the consequences of migration.
For now, these are only parallels with a fictional future. But speculative scenarios are built from political and social forces that already exist. What look like separate problems today may eventually become links in a single chain of events.